Is an old home worth it?

As designers who work daily with historic homes—inside and out—we’re often asked a simple but loaded question: Is an old home really worth it? The answer, like the buildings themselves, is complex. Old houses come with undeniable challenges, but when viewed through the lens of longevity, craftsmanship, and long-term value, they offer something increasingly rare in today’s housing landscape.

There’s no denying the realities. Older homes may require ongoing maintenance, thoughtful upgrades, and patience. Mechanical systems can be outdated, layouts may reflect another era, and restoration work often demands specialized trades and materials. These factors can feel daunting to a both new and seasoned home owners, especially when compared to the apparent ease of new construction.

But what older homes offer in return is substance. Many were built with solid masonry, old-growth lumber, plaster walls, and hand-finished details that are difficult—if not impossible—to replicate today. Their construction favors durability and sustainability over speed, and their materials have already proven to last 100 years or longer. When properly maintained and restored, these homes are not fragile—they are remarkably resilient. Craftsmanship is another defining advantage. From intricate millwork and proportioned rooms to thoughtfully placed windows and exterior detailing, historic homes reflect a level of care and intention that’s often absent from modern speculative building. The elements of old homes weren’t designed to follow trends; they were designed to endure.

There’s also the matter of physical location, city, and neighborhood. Older homes are typically found in established neighborhoods with mature trees, walkable streets, architectural cohesion, and proximity to city centers. These are qualities that cannot be manufactured overnight and consistently contribute to long-term desirability and property value. Preservation-minded improvements tend to enhance—not diminish—a home’s appeal in these settings, and well preserved neighborhoods often remain some of the most desirable spaces in American suburban cities.

Finally, from a design standpoint, old homes also offer a flexibility that’s often overlooked. Contemporary interior trends are ditching stuffy lace doilies and grandmother's pewter tea set. With thoughtful planning, old homes can adapt beautifully to contemporary living while retaining character. When modern interventions are handled with restraint and respect, the result is a home that feels both contemporary, grounded in history, and fully functional.

So, is an old home worth it? From our perspective, yes—unequivocally (we are in the business of old homes after all). Not because it’s easy, but because it’s lasting. However, we also recognize that an old home often falls under the TME (time, money & energy) categorization, requiring all three to reach their full potential. In our experience, emphasis on the "E" often produces the greatest return (e.g., energy in = beautiful results out). An old home represents an investment in quality materials, enduring design, and a sense of place that grows richer over time. For those willing to steward them thoughtfully, historic homes don’t just hold their value—they deepen it.

-LH